Pietro Pontio

Sometimes the best way to determine historical practice is to learn about when things went wrong... like with Pietro Pontio! Early Music Sources provides some excellent context for what was going on (both good and bad) in this situation.

Bach and the mob

The "turba" choruses in Bach's St. John Passion are some of the catchiest and fun to sing - and I think that's exactly what Bach intended. Going along with the mob and being swept up by their energy is easy and fun, until you (hopefully) realize you're calling for someone's death...

AND the anti-semitism in the St. John Passion is NOT OK. It's fine to present this piece, but it needs context. My experience had to do with idea that we all are complicit in the actions of the mob. No anti-semitism, yes to personal responsibility and examining your actions.